9 year ‘Monster-in-Law’ rental lands woman in jail

9 year ‘Monster-in-Law’ rental lands woman in jail

A NIGHT IN JAIL WORTH A LATE MOVIE?: Kayla Finley allegedly never returned her rented VHS copy of "Monster-in-Law" to a video store that is now out of business. Photo: YouTube

A film fan from South Carolina has been arrested and jailed for failing to return a copy of Jennifer Lopez and Jane Fonda’s movie “Monster-in-Law” to her local video store.

Kayla Finley, 27, was taken into custody last week for failure to return a video rental to Dalton Video.

She held onto the rental for over nine years, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

She was booked on petty larceny charges when she went to a local police station on Thursday to file a criminal complaint of her own, and officers checked her records.

She was jailed for the night and released on Friday morning after paying bail.

Finley insists she never received the warnings from the video store or the warrant, which was originally sent to her in 2005, and she had forgotten she still had the movie.

In a note on, she writes, “It’s obvious that Pickens County has nothing better to do. I fully intend on fighting this, it’s ridiculous that this had to happen to me.”

Recent Headlines

in Local

Harold Square project gets another approval from city

Photo Credit Sara McCloskey

Approval was needed once again because it was initially looked at by city planners two years ago.

in Local

Clayton back in jail after violating law again


Thomas Clayton is behind bars in Steuben County for violating an order of protection after he posted bail earlier this week.

in Local

39-year-old man arrested for drug trafficking in Ithaca-area

sterling mug

Officials say a warrant was issued after an investigation into crack cocaine and heroin trafficking.

in Local

Missing Humpty Dumpty from campground located

spruce row

A Humpty Dumpty statue stolen from Spruce Row Campground was recovered from a group of RIT students this week.

in National, World

Obama makes pitch to win support for Pacific trade pact


U.S. President Barack Obama kicked off a sales pitch for a 12-nation Pacific Rim trade agreement.