News

NY Court: Some police lies to suspects are unfair

Photo: WHCU

New York’s highest court says police can go too far lying to suspects, making confessions inadmissible as evidence when the lies told during interrogations become “patently coercive.”

The Court of Appeals, ruling unanimously, has thrown out the murder conviction of 31-year-old Adrian Thomas and ordered a new trial without his purported confession.

The Troy man’s infant son died with a head injury and infection in 2008.

Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman writes that investigators improperly told Thomas they’d pick up his wife if he didn’t confess to injuring his son and that his already brain dead child would die if he didn’t explain how the child hit his head.

They also told him 67 times it was an accident, 14 times that he wouldn’t be arrested and eight times that he’d be going home.

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press.

Recent Headlines

in Local

Opt-out movement likely to continue this school year

Fresh
school3

School officials say students who opt-out of tests won't stop them from having to teach to those tests due to state rules.

in Local

Woman dies from injuries after Finger Lakes hay ride accident

ambulance

Authorities say Penn Yan woman died Wednesday at Rochester hospital, days after hay ride accident on Sunday near Keuka Lake

in Local

NY lawmakers, workers address on-call scheduling

workers

Workers say on-call scheduling is unfair and can lead to missed paychecks and disruption of their lives.

in Local

Commons business owner arrested for tax fraud

Crime 3

Jonathan Pargh of Ithaca faces tax fraud charges for under-reporting sales tax revenue at his businesses.